Sunday, April 4, 2010

Blog reviews

Blog Reviews

The first blog I chose to review was Kaye Robinson's EUUC 58025: Culture and Ice.

Before I even talk about content, I want to say how much I like Kaye's blog's layout. I love the picture bar down the right side of the page, the header, the color scheme - all of it. Clearly she took time to make this her own. This is also obviously the blog of someone who really lives in Alaska because they love it! Aside from living vicariously through someone else's awesome adventure pictures, I have to admit that I have a soft spot for Kaye's blog simply because I lived in Fairbanks for 7 years and still miss it. :)

This blog is about more than great pictures, however. I really enjoyed reading Kaye's perspective each week. Her stories from her life in different parts of Alaska were meaningful, humorous, and informative. I felt that she spoke from real knowledge and experience rather than unsupported opinion. I also noticed that I usually came away from reading her blog with a new insight or a different perspective than I'd had before. Additionally, Kaye is a good writer. Her blogs are engaging, well-written, and well-referenced without being academically dry. Thank you Kaye!



The second blog I chose to review was Dan's Alaska Connections.

Dan's blog contains many of the same qualities that I liked so much about Kaye's blog. He writes with authenticity, clarity, and thoughtfulness. Another aspect of Dan's blog that I really enjoyed were the stories he shared about how he used resources with his students. I particularly liked the way Dan has his students doing real science. In my opinion, the more "real" our lessons are, the more students will be engaged and the more value they will get from their education. It's so great to see a teacher out there doing this kind of work with their students.

Finally, every time I read one of Dan's blogs, I came away with new information, even if I'd just finished researching and posting on the same topic. We usually came at a topic from a different angle, which made reading his blog a refreshing experience. I very much like reading posts that get me out of my own head and make me take a second look at my own opinions and perspective. Dan's blog did that, and offered a series of extremely useful links and resources as well. Thank you Dan!

Saturday, March 13, 2010

Final Project blog

Final Project Essential Question:
How can digital resources and effective teaching methods be used to integrate Alaska Native ways of knowing and Western scientific methods in order to create greater understanding of, and interest in, geosciences for students?

Lesson / unit ideas:
Enduring Understandings:
Climate change is occurring in the Anchorage Bowl area, and is impacting organisms in the local community. People can have a positive effect in mitigating climate changes.

Essential Questions:
How is the climate changing in the Anchorage Bowl? How will these changes impact the living organisms (including humans) in our area? What can you do to mitigate these impacts?

Unit Objectives / Goals:
Students will collect data about local climate change from both Western and Native experts, using a combination of personal interviews and research. They will analyze data from all their sources to summarize what climate changes are occurring in the Anchorage Bowl area. Finally, students will come up with a plan to mitigate the climate changes they have identified.

Rationale for lesson / unit:
Students in my school are an interesting mix of kids who are very active in and aware of their natural surroundings and typical “city kids” who hardly know what a moose looks like and say “EEEW!” when they get dirt on their shoes. Studying the effects of climate change on their own local area and the organisms (including humans) that live there is a way to engage both groups of kids. This is also a way to expose both groups of kids to the value of local expertise / Native ways of knowing as well as giving them experience in doing research by more western methods. Finally, students need to realize that humans can affect their local environment, both positively and negatively. Once they have identified the problems, they have a responsibility to do what they can to help solve them.


Links to resources used:
Online climate research:
http://easthighlibrary.wikispaces.com/
This site has links to many databases as well as guidelines for doing better internet searches, citing resources, etc.

http://www.rssweather.com/climate/Alaska/Anchorage/
http://pafc.arh.noaa.gov/climate.php
These two sites are a sampling of the web sites that have information specific to the Anchorage area. Many others are available.


Personal interviews / research:
http://www.nativescience.org/issues/tk.htm
This site defines traditional knowledge and does a great side-by-side comparison with western scientific knowledge.

http://elders.uaa.alaska.edu/reports/yr2_3listening.pdf
This document is useful in describing the importance of listening in the Alaska Native tradition, as well as describing what it really means to be an Elder in a community.

http://www.teachersdomain.org/asset/ean08_doc_lpaelderint/
http://www.teachersdomain.org/asset/ean08_doc_lpaelderroom/
These two sites give excellent guidelines for how to respectfully request and conduct an interview with an Elder or other community member.


Teachers’ Domain resources:
http://www.teachersdomain.org/resource/ipy07.sci.ess.earthsys.arcticland/
“Changing Arctic Landscape”

http://www.teachersdomain.org/resource/ipy07.sci.ess.watcyc.saobclimate/
“Observations of Climate Change”

http://www.teachersdomain.org/resource/ean08.sci.ess.earthsys.sanature/
“Take Action for Nature and Your Community”


Mitigation resources:
These resources differ depending on what the students elect to try to change. However, here are some useful general resources for mitigation based on reducing human impacts:

Personal water use conservation:
http://www.awwu.biz/website/environment/environment_frame.htm

Water quality monitoring:
http://anchoragecreeks.org/pages/monitoring_adoptastream.php
http://anchoragecreeks.org/pages/action_main.php

Energy conservation:
http://earth911.com/location/california/flex-your-power/

Anchorage solid waste recycling;
http://www.muni.org/departments/sws/pages/default.aspx

Module IX blog

Essential Question:
How are climate, terrestrial ice and Alaskan indigenous cultures all connected?

This module could have been titled “all the aspects of ice that I’ve never really paid attention to”. When I was brainstorming for this blog, I realized virtually every sentence began with “I had never realized…” or “I had never thought of…” I also am feeling resource guilt this week, because I don’t feel that I’ve brought anything new to the table so much as I’ve been handed a banquet of goodies and am using my blog to rant about how wonderful they all are. Other than being properly humbling, I feel that this module has really offered me information that will help me better teach climate change to my students.

To begin, I had never really thought of how different the Antarctic is from the Arctic (aside from our lack of penguins), but the differences caused by being surrounded by mainly glacial ice vs. mainly sea ice are dramatic. The fact that Antarctica has 70% of the world’s fresh water (and yet is bone dry) was news to me as well. Aside from its importance to circulating ocean currents, the impact of melting shelf ice really hits home when you see a massive shelf fall off its parent continent into the ocean. The “If the Ice Melts” and “When Sea Levels Attack” resources graphically illustrate what will happen to sea levels when Antarctic ice melts, as well as why it may be best not to invest in any real estate in Miami (or Venice).

This led me to think of the different climate impacts that can result, depending on which type of ice is melting. Even if you stick to land, river ice has a different impact from glacial ice, which has a different impact than permafrost or ice shelves or lake ice and so on. It’s no wonder people get confused about the effects of climate change! Fortunately (or unfortunately), there are clear Alaskan examples of each variety of impact that can be used to hook students. (Photo: Nenana Ice Classic website)


In particular, I really enjoyed the animations and time-lapse photo loops that allowed me to see 1 – what has actually been happening with glacial ice melt and snowfall, and 2 – what could happen if these trends continue. I teach students who are just transitioning into abstract thinking, and they often have trouble understanding abstract concepts or projecting into the future. These visuals really are worth the proverbial thousand words. I could talk all day and not make the same impact as watching the before and after pictures of dozens of glaciers. (Photo: 1919 image of Athbasca Glacier, Jasper National Park, Canada, courtesy National Archives of Canada, from the Wheeler Survery; 2005 image © Gary Braasch)

Finally, the information given in this unit is so easy to make relevant to my students. Whether it’s the melting permafrost leading to worse fire seasons or glacial melt causing sea level rises that threaten coastal communities, this is happening in places we live and to people we know.

Module VIII blog

Essential Question:
How are Arctic sea-ice, climate and culture all connected?

Arctic sea ice plays an important role in both Earth's temperature regulation and in the cultures of circumpolar peoples. From a climate standpoint, less polar ice (see photo below, NASA) means that the amount of light reflected back into space is reduced, which leads to increased temperatures on Earth, which increases the amount of polar ice that melts, and so on in a positive feedback loop. From a cultural standpoint, less ice could mean a serious shortage of food gained by traditional means, the loss of transportation routes, and potentially a total loss of culture.
Sea water freezes later than fresh water due to the different freezing points of saltwater vs. fresh water. Also, even when salt water does freeze, it tends to push the salt out before the ice forms. This means that the water beneath sea ice is even saltier than usual, and therefore denser. In simple terms, the dense salty water sinks, warmer equatorial water flows north into the space left by the sinking polar water, and the end result is thermohaline circulation in the oceans (as discussed in Module V). As less polar ice forms, it follows that less of this dense salt water will be produced, and that these deep ocean currents will be weakened, which will alter the climate.

A further consequence of less persistent sea ice is that as ice ages, more and more of the salt trickles out of it, and eventually it can be used for drinking water. Alaska Native peoples typically will use this "multi-year" ice as a source of clean water. Less ice persisting from year to year means less clean drinking water. Also, changing ice conditions increase the danger for hunters. There has been an increase in the number of accidents on the ice, nearly all related to thinner, mushier ice. (Broken sea ice photo, NSIDC)

Both western scientists and Native peoples are concerned about the effects of climate change, and they are beginning to work together for the benefit of all, both in the Arctic and elsewhere. Alaska Natives and other circumpolar people who have been living close to the sea-ice have minute and long-term observations on sea-ice in their local areas. Western scientists have access to data from many regions as well as tools like computerized climate models. As the video with Steve MacLean illustrated, it's also a benefit for Alaska Native people to be trained scientists. Ideally, they can use both traditional Native knowledge and western scientific knowledge to make positive changes in the places they love.

Module VII blog

Essential Question:
How is Earth's climate connected to its geological, biological and cultural systems?


There seems to be a pretty deep misunderstanding of weather vs. climate for many Americans. We have one unseasonable snowstorm (photo by Kelly Auer) or cold snap and people are ready to dismiss climate change as a myth. I get SO tired of telling otherwise intelligent people to examine the data vs. making their decision on what they heard on a Fox News blurb last night. I loved the Information is Beautiful links in this module, and will definitely use them both with students and grown-ups.

I think that the first priority for me when teaching a unit on climate to my students would be to differentiate carefully between climate and weather. Some of the excellent resources on Teachers' Domain and NASA (as well as a really cool interactive Carbon Cycle game) can help kids build an understanding of the long-term nature of climate, as well as the importance of carbon. Once students are sure of what the word climate actually means, we can look at our current climate situation and intelligently compare it to past situations to see 1) if there have been changes, and 2) possible causes for any changes we do see.

I initially thought that only geological and biological processes could directly affect Earth's climate, but a moment of reflection showed me how foolish that was. After all, American culture has lead us to use our natural resources in one way while the culture of Switzerland, for example, has lead them to use their natural resources in very different ways. Culture and climate are interactive, each one having an effect on the other.

The question I like to address with my students is: what do we do now? Recognizing that there is a problem is important, but it's equally important to try to find solutions. Teachers' Domain has some great resources showing Alaskan kids taking steps to take action in their communities. There are examples of small and large projects. As part of the unit, I would like to have a capstone project where students identified an environmental concern in their community, and then planned and carried out a project to correct or at least mitigate it. (Photo by Kelly Auer)

In Anchorage, we're fortunate to have several programs that allow students to be involved in projects that result in real data collection and real change in our community. At minimum, the Anchorage Waterways Council sponsors a Creek Clean-up day every spring that students can participate in. At a more involved level, students can Adopt-A-Stream and be directly involved in collecting data. I myself have worked with my Biology classes to collect macroinvertebrate data for local streams for the Alaska Stream Team database (Photo by Kelly Auer). I really liked the "Alaska Native Teens" article on Teachers' Domain. It's an excellent example of kids being involved with both the Native and the western science sides of an issue.

I feel like this week's module was a gold mine of good resources for teaching climate change. I hereby notify all and sundry that I am going to profit by Clay's hard work and pirate most of the resources for my own lessons.

Saturday, March 6, 2010

Module VI blog

Essential Question:
How are the Earth, atmosphere and cultures all connected?

Earth formed some 5 billion years ago, basically by the accretion of material that was spiraling around what became the Sun. Similar to other planets (and moons) in our solar system, the Earth's gravitational pull was strong enough to hold a collection of gases near the surface of the planet. We call this collection of gases an atmosphere, although the original atmosphere of Earth was anything but hospitable to life as we know it now. (Picture from Aerospaceweb.org)


Over time, and through the action of many of those geological processes that we've already studied, Earth's atmosphere changed. It became richer in nitrogen, oxygen, and water, and poorer in carbon dioxide and sulfates. It has been hypothesized that this last change was largely due to the first living organisms, now known as Archaea, some of which took in sulfates and produced oxygen as a waste product. As time went on, the atmosphere became so rich in oxygen that many of these organisms could not survive in it and retreated further and further into anoxic regions of Earth. Today we find these Archaea mainly in oxygen-poor areas that are hostile to modern life - deep ocean trenches, hot springs, and the intestines of cows, to name a few. (Photo: Octopus Spring at Yellowstone National Park, by U.C. Berkeley.)

When I was thinking of how the Earth, atmosphere, and cultures are all connected, I thought of the fate of those Archaea bacteria. They had lived as the dominant (only) life forms on the planet for literally a billion years before poisoning their environment with their waste products to the point where they were driven into near-extinction. It doesn't take much imagination to draw a parallel between the Archaea and humanity's current predicament. Will we too produce enough toxins that we will threaten the extinction of all human cultures on Earth? (Photo: Badlands, by Kelly Auer.)



Although all humans are feeling the impacts of the global distribution of pollutants, not all humans are equally responsible for producing the pollutants. For example, in 2005 North America produced nearly twice as much carbon dioxide per capita as Europe, and more than 5.5 times as Asia and Oceania. So how is it that the pollutants produced by a few are impacting 6.6 billion people world-wide?

Google Earth's Weather layer is great for showing how air currents can draw particulates north from their production points lower down in North America up to Alaska and the rest of the Arctic. The clouds shown in the picture from Google Earth (to the right) sweep up the western coast of the United States and along the coast of Alaska, for example.


A more global example (from the United Nations' Environmental Programme) is shown to the left. Prevailing air currents carry the pollutants from most of the heavy polluters in the Northern Hemisphere to the Arctic.

This is where the impact to Alaskan cultures comes in. Some pollutants accumulate in living organisms, especially when they are not water soluble. This bioaccumulation is having a critical impact in the Arctic, partly because humans more frequently eat organisms that are secondary, tertiary, and even quaternary consumers, and partly because many people in the Arctic still practice a subsistance lifestyle.

Studies have shown that some Arctic mothers have consumed these concentrated pollutants in traditional foods and are secreting them in their breast milk. This puts people practicing traditional subsistance lifestyle in a terrible dilemma. They either endanger their health and the health of their children by consuming possibly tainted traditional foods, or they endanger their culture by abandoning traditional foods and hunting / gathering methods for store-bought food.

This is one of the grimmest blogs I've written, but I can't see a way to make it any lighter. This is a critical issue, and the people in Alaska who are most impacted right now are also the people who historically have had the least voice in policy and law in their own state, much less in the rest of the U.S. The one bright spot I see is that the impact of the global distribution of pollutants has spread to the point where people as a whole are going to have to do something about it for their own sakes.

Saturday, February 27, 2010

Module V Blog

Essential Question:
How are climate, cultures and oceans all connected?

Climate is affected by the ocean and the oceans are affected by climate: the two are inextricably linked. A brief look at the simplest version of the water cycle should be enough to convince most people that whatever happens to the ocean, happens to the climate and vice versa. There is a wealth of data showing the relationship between climate (in coastal areas especially) and the ocean. We are perhaps only beginning to realize that climate in non-coastal areas may be equally affected by changes in the ocean, but the essential relationship between water and climate is irrefutable.

For example,
in northern and central California, coastal upwelling affects the coastal climate by bringing cool water to the surface of the ocean and producing San Francisco's famous fogs. In more dramatic fashion, upwelling cold ocean water reduces the likelihood of cyclones (hurricanes), because these weather events rely on extremely warm water surface temperatures. The incredibly destructive hurricanes of the 2005 season (including Katrina: see image at right) were due to the warmer surface ocean temperatures recorded that year. There is currently no consensus on whether these warmer surface temperatures are a result of human activity or not, but it's clear that warmer surface water = more severe storms.

Cultures are profoundly linked to the climate of their geographic location. Witness the Mesopotamian "cradle of civilization" that developed at the confluence of two great rivers. If the climate of the area had changed and dried up the flow of the Tigris or Euphrates, you can be assured that the cultures of the region would have been very different because the ways of farming, traveling, and holding commerce in the area would either have disappeared or altered dramatically to suit the new conditions.

We are no different in modern times. Anyone who has traveled from one region of the United States to another knows that each area has its own culture that is, at least in part, influenced by the climate of its geographic location.
Northern cultures celebrate the return of the sun after a long dark winter while southern cultures celebrate the return of rains and coolness after a baking hot season. Different traditions, foods, songs, and skills revolve around the climate and geography where people live.

Because of this relationship between the oceans, climate, and culture, changes in the ocean or climate will inevitably lead to changes in cultures. To take a dramatic example, Hurricanes Katrina and Rita changed the culture of an entire region of the United States when they struck in fall of 2005. The coastal regions of Louisiana and Mississippi were the worst hit, and people evacuated by the thousands. Many historical sites were destroyed, and some of the old-time residents of the area either died in the storms and their aftermath or never returned. As a result, the cultures of these coastal areas are profoundly affected, both by the loss of wisdom in the person of their elders, and by the loss of history in their oldest structures.

The same theme holds true in Alaska. Because ocean temperatures are warmer, sea ice forms later in the year and breaks up sooner. Because the sea ice is present for a shorter period of time, polar bear populations are suffering and people are less able to hunt polar bears. Traditions of hunting, ice survival, and food preparation are being put on hold, and possibly will be lost. On land, warmer temperatures and changes in rainfall cause different plants to grow in an area. Local people can’t harvest the same plants and berries they always harvested, or must change their traditional practices. Hunting and gathering practices are essential to different Alaska Native cultures, and when the hunting and gathering practices are lost or changes, culture is lost or changed.

I think that, especially with Alaskan kids, this linkage between culture, climate, and the oceans is an important one. So many Alaskans make their living from the ocean, and, unfortunately, those livings sometimes conflict with one another (for example, pollutions dumped by cruise ships in fisheries areas). I would start a unit by exploring water’s relationship with thermal energy – the capacity of water to absorb and retain heat, and the time it takes to do both. There are some cool demo’s in this module that I can easily take directly into my classroom with the additional benefit of working in skills like graphing, and since the Celsius system was developed based on the freezing point of water, it makes the math and graphing very easy. Once the students understand the relationship between water and climate, it should be easy to bring in examples of how climate affects culture.

Sunday, February 21, 2010

Module IV blog

Essential Question:
How do stories of cataclysmic events help inform students about geosciences and cultures?

Students are instantly interested in stories that involve catastrophe. You have only to look at the typical evening news broadcast to know that this trait is simple human nature. Using stories of cataclysmic events provides a "hook" that engages students instantly. Once the students are engaged, you can sneak some actual learning in before they know what's hit them.

The wonderful example provided during this module was the 1958 Lituya Bay megatsunami, and specifically, the video interview of the father and son who miraculously rode it out on their fishing boat. Once students are engaged by this amazing story, their teacher could transition to the history of tsunami in Lituya Bay, including why it is geologically such a magnet for these enormous and destructive events. The images in Google Earth showing the tsunami swash (lighter green in the photo) along the Bay also provide a powerful connection between the story and current reality for students. (Image captured from Google Earth.)

I have some decent basic knowledge of geology, but the Lituya Bay scenario taught me something new about the less obvious causes of tsunami. I especially loved how Google Earth enabled me to see the diabolical combination of narrow inlet and plate boundary that ensure that Lituya Bay will always be subject to tsunami events. (Image captured from Google Earth.)

There is also an easy tie to the cultural impacts the historic tsunami of Lituya Bay have had. White explorers in the area record that there were settlements of Alaska Natives in 1788. However, by the late 1800's, the settlements had been abandoned, possibly due to destruction by tsunami waves. By the time another tsunami hit in 1936, the only residents of the area were a few white men living on Cenotaph Island. Effectively, the area had become uninhabitable because of the nature of its geology. The Native people who once had lived in Lituya Bay had had to relocate and adapt to a new area, or risk perishing in the unpredictable and dangerous tsunami that plagued the Bay.

Once students are engaged in using Google Earth, it would be easy to extend it as a teaching tool: measuring the Fairweather fault and other objects, and comparing distances with things like the width of the lower 48 to give them a little better perspective on some of the sizes involved. For example, I have lived in Alaska for nearly 20 years, and I never really realized the Aleutian Trench was nearly as wide as the width of lower 48 until I measured it with the Ruler in Google Earth. (Images captured from Google Earth.)


...is the same length as...






Stories of cataclysmic geological events in Alaska also have the benefit of being extremely immediate and real to our students. I've often thought that Alaskan geology teachers have an incredible edge over teachers in virtually any other U.S. state (except, possibly, Hawaii). For example, students who have been in South Central for at least a couple of years remember hoping for a free day from school due to volcanic ash from Redoubt. Students who have family who've been here longer have grown up with stories of the 1964 Good Friday earthquake and all its terrible devastation.


The effects of the 1964 earthquake on the town of Valdez would be an excellent capstone lesson to allow students to synthesize their knowledge of geological phenomena and their impact on both the physical landscape and the people who inhabit it. I would have students look at the Google Earth images (left, and below right) of the old Valdez and the new Valdez townsites. Looking at the topography and geology of the area, why might the people of Valdez have decided to move the community after the earthquake and (most especially) the tsunami?

Tuesday, February 9, 2010

Module III blog

Essential Question:
How are landscapes formed and how, in turn, are cultures shaped by their landscapes?

I was born and raised in Green Bay, Wisconsin. My family lived in town, but all of our many relatives lived in the country a short distance away.




The town of Green Bay is split by the Fox River, flowing north to empty into the bay itself: an inlet of Lake Michigan. A narrow peninsula of land separates the town from Lake Michigan proper, and shelters it from the worst of the lake-effect wind and snow. The marshy plains that line the bay quickly give way to well-watered, rolling farmland. Northeastern Wisconsin is only saved from pure flatness by the occasional gentle hill left by the glacial action of the last ice age. (Images captured from Google Earth.)


Most of the area surrounding Green Bay is neatly chopped into small parcels, often farmed by the same families for decades. My family has been in this area, farming and raising cattle, for about 150 years. (Photo: Kelly Auer)






I chose to visit Kotzebue using Google Earth because, in some ways, it reminds me of where I grew up in Wisconsin. Kotzebue, like Green Bay, is located on the verge of a large body of water, with all the wind, water, and weather that entails.
(Image captured using Google Earth)





The landscape in the Kotzebue area was formed by a combination of these forces, largely the erosion and deposition caused by wind and water. This is a community concern, as erosion is still eating away at the coastline, although it is nothing like the catastrophic erosion experienced in other coastal communities (such as Shishmaref). (Photo: Army Corps of Engineers Digital Visual Library, photographer unknown)


The people of Kotzebue, like the people of Green Bay, have been in the area for generations, living off the land in a manner similar to that practiced by their parents and grandparents. They are largely Inupiaq, and live by fishing the waters of Kotzebue Sound, as well as by harvesting plants and animals from the surrounding land. (Photo: Al Grillo, Associated Press)


People in both communities are close to their families and neighbors and support one another, a characteristic that can be the difference between starving and surviving in a bad harvest year. Their lifestyle and culture are clear reflections of their geographical location.

I have physically visited both Kotzebue and Green Bay, but using Google Earth to explore them was a completely different experience for me. Being able to compare and contrast the landscapes of Alaska and Wisconsin really led me to look at the familiar geography of my home city in a completely different way. Using my fresh look at the familiar geography to try to understand the culture of the area where I was raised also really helped me to extrapolate and relate the culture of an unfamiliar area to its geography.

For example, it never before occurred to me that I had anything in common with an Alaska Native youth who was one generation out of the village; but I was a midwestern youth, one generation off the farm, who found herself 4,000 miles from home. There is a strange disconnect between struggling to retain the value of what your parents and grandparents have taught you and assimilating yourself to the culture in which you find yourself. Keeping my values and sense of self while thriving in my new culture was a balance that I struggled with, and I didn't even have the barriers of language and ethnic differences to overcome.

This lesson also led me to think of how useful this exercise could be with my students, who often have not had the opportunity to travel widely or experience cultures other than the familiar one in which they were raised. Using Google Earth in conjunction with other tools (internet searches, etc.) students could begin to experience other points of view as well as finding similarities between themselves and those they instinctively think of as completely "other". In addition to opening a different perspective to urban students, this type of exercise may prove useful in easing the transition to urban life for students who have only lived in rural Alaska.

Friday, February 5, 2010

Module II Blog

Essential Question:
How is everything connected from the perspectives of indigenous peoples and Western scientists? What are the advantages to knowing both ways?

The Western view does not deny the unity of the universe, but it differs sharply from the indigenous viewpoint in how the universe is best to be understood. In Western science, people generally choose one small area and specialize in it. Their knowledge and experience within that area may be deep, but they seldom have that depth in more than a few areas.

This differs from traditional Native knowledge, which views the world and the living creatures in it (including humanity) as parts of a whole that must be understood in the relationship they bear to that whole. That understanding is profound and contains much of what a Westerner would consider science. In contrast to the Western scientist, an indigenous person would be less likely to have deep detailed knowledge of soil’s mineral composition and much more likely to know the type of plants that grow in that soil, the animals that eat the plants, and ways to use the plants and animals for food or shelter.

Additionally, spirituality is an inseparable part of the indigenous understanding of the universe. The Inuit culture believes in a unifying spirit, Sila, (similar to the Great Spirit of many Native American peoples) which embodies wholeness and embraces all creation. Western science has deliberately distanced itself from including spiritual beliefs, and instead focuses on ways of understanding that can be quantified or proven experimentally.

From the viewpoint of a teacher or student, there are advantages to both ways of knowing. Research shows that students of all levels learn most effectively when we teachers make lessons engaging and relevant to our students. Therefore, it is my job to make sure the information students learn is connected in meaningful ways to the world around them and to the knowledge they already possess. This connectivity is inherent in the indigenous perspective.

From this perspective, a well taught lesson in Biology would not only give the student important and useful information about bacteria, but would allow the student to understand and connect the information to their life (for example, how to avoid and cure bacterial illness) and to concepts learned in other classes (the effect of bacterial plagues on human culture and history).

Western science has the advantage of a systematic, widespread, and diverse body of knowledge. People have been able to compile very detailed knowledge in a wide array of fields across the globe. Why should a student have to give up the wisdom of their culture to make use of the wisdom found in another? Doesn’t it just make sense to take advantage of what is best in each?

I can encourage all my students to value the indigenous perspective by asking Elders and local experts to share their specialized knowledge with our classes and highlighting the value of this expertise during lessons. I can also point out opportunities for indigenous students to continue their Western science education in a supportive cultural environment, such as through ANSEP at UAA. In this way, perhaps all students will be able to take advantage of the benefits of each way of knowing.

Wednesday, January 27, 2010

Up and running...

I seem to have managed to create a blog and edit the settings successfully. One small step for (wo)man... We'll see how it goes when I actually have to include content!